🎣 Welcome to Fish Tales Customs
At Fish Tales Customs, we don’t just make fishing lures—we create fish-catching confidence.
Every color we design is built with one goal in mind: help you catch more fish. From bold, high-visibility patterns to realistic, forage-matching finishes, our custom colors are crafted to perform in real-world conditions—whether you’re fishing clear water, stained lakes, or chasing bites in low light.
Fish your confidence bait without ever compromising on presentation.
This isn’t mass-produced.
This is custom-built performance.
🔥 Fish Different. Fish Better.
Because when your bait stands out…
your results do too.
WE USE ONLY NEW, OUT OF THE PACKAGE BAITS FOR CUSTOM PAINTING!! Made to order with any color or pattern, on any style bait!
We also offer repainting of your own baits. You can pick one of our many color options, or we can customize a design completely unique to you!
60k +
Custom Lures Sold
13
Years in Business
Countless
Happy Customers
Reviews
“Quality customs and outstanding service. This angler/lure artist is top notch. The bladed jigs he made me took a beating during prespawn but they’re tough as nails. Very well made.”
“Custom painted baits are the best in the area. Seems to be the only thing I can catch fish on! Great live bait. No complaints!”
About Us
While we specialize in creating unique custom painted baits, we started as a bait and tackle shop located in Oshkosh, WI.
We carry the tackle, the live bait, and the info to make your day on the water a success!
If you are in the area, stop in and say hello.
